Response by Built by Nature to the Environmental Audit Committee Report: Sustainability of the Built Environment
Today, a UK parliamentary inquiry published a critical report into the sustainability of the built environment. The report came from the Environmental Audit Committee (EAC), a cross-party parliamentary select committee that shines a light on Government’s progress on environmental issues. Amongst its findings are a raft of recommendations to unlock an increased use of timber in UK construction.
It is promising to see such a prominent group of MPs from across the major political parties call for timber’s role in mitigating the climate crisis to be recognised and accelerated. For the first time from a group of British parliamentarians, the EAC noted that “many of the academics and architects we heard from recognized that the use of timber (subject to forestry management) in place of concrete, masonry and steel was one of the most successful strategies to reduce embodied carbon”
It goes on to add that data exists to back up these claims, highlighting that “this conclusion is borne out by analysis from the International Energy Agency, which conducted meta-analysis of over 80, mostly European, case studies of embodied carbon in individual buildings”
Built by Nature’s network in the UK is bringing together industry stakeholders to work together on solutions to some of the barriers that the EAC highlights, including issues arising from fire risk and insurance. The network is coalescing around a number of proactive initiatives to tackle these major challenges and accelerate the use of timber.
We’re really pleased to see this progress, and it’s great to see our own UK Networks Lead Joe Giddings cited in the report, as well as Prof. Michael Ramage from our partner organisation, the Centre for Natural Material Innovation, who gave evidence in Parliament last year.
Below is the press release for the report:
REPORT: Sustainability of the Built Environment
Emissions must be reduced in the construction of buildings if the UK is to meet net zero, MPs warn
From residential to commercial buildings, the UK’s built environment is responsible for 25% of the UK’s greenhouse gas emissions. The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) warns that to date there has been a lack of Government impetus or policy levers to assess and reduce these emissions. With climate deadlines looming, urgent action is needed.
To reduce the levels of CO2 in construction, for instance when using cement and steel, EAC recommends that the Government introduce a mandatory requirement for whole-life carbon assessments for buildings. This requirement should be fully incorporated in building regulations and the planning system. Such an assessment would calculate the emissions from the construction, maintenance and demolition of a building, and from the energy used in its day-to-day operation. The UK is currently lagging behind countries such as The Netherlands and France which have established mandatory whole-life carbon assessments for their built environment.
Once these assessments are in place, the Government should develop carbon targets for buildings to align with the UK’s net zero goals. A clear timeframe for introducing whole-life carbon assessments, and ratcheting targets, should be set by the Government by the end of 2022 at the latest, and they should be introduced not later than December 2023.
Retrofit and reuse of buildings, keeping the carbon locked in, should be prioritised over new build. While the Government states it is prioritising retrofit and reuse, the Committee is concerned that reforms to permitted development rights appear to have created an incentive for demolition and new-build over retrofit. The Government must therefore urgently evaluate the impact of recent reforms to ensure that retrofit and reuse are prioritised.
Where retrofit is not possible, EAC recommends efficient and more effective use of low-carbon building materials. The Government’s investment in the development of low-carbon cements is welcome, and mandating whole-life carbon assessments for buildings could encourage the use of more recycled steel and other recycled building materials. EAC recognises the potential of timber as a low-carbon construction material, though the Committee identified significant hurdles to its wider use, such as appropriate sourcing, enhanced tree planting and a current skills gap in timber use in construction.
As EAC has identified in previous reports, the UK is facing a chronic skills gap in energy efficiency and retrofit. Without these vital green skills in the UK economy, net zero ambitions will fall flat. EAC is therefore reiterating its previous recommendation that a retrofit strategy and upskilling programme be developed and published. In addition, EAC recommends that training in undertaking whole-life carbon assessments is made accessible through the education system.
Environmental Audit Committee Chairman, Rt Hon Philip Dunne MP, said:
“From homes to offices, retail units to hospitality venues, our buildings have a significant amount of locked-in carbon, which is wasted each time they get knocked down to be rebuilt, a process which produces yet more emissions.
“Ministers must address this urgently. Promising steps are being taken: for instance, the Levelling-Up, Housing and Communities Secretary of State recently paused the demolition and retrofit of Marks and Spencer on Oxford Street on environmental grounds.
“But much more needs to be done, and baseline standards for action need to be established. Mandatory whole-life carbon assessments, and targets to crack down on embodied carbon, provide part of the answer. Constructors and developers can then determine which low-carbon materials, such as timber and recycled steel, they can use.
“As in many other areas in the drive to net zero, the UK must have the green skills to make its low carbon future a reality. Before the summer recess in July, I urge the Government to publish a retrofit strategy and upskilling programme that can ensure the UK economy will have the green jobs necessary to deliver a low-carbon built environment.”
Read the report: